deny_overrides_sell_not_amzn

A permit + forbid pair showing deny-overrides semantics: SellShares is permitted in general, but a forbid carves out AMZN. Because forbid always wins, source order does not matter — the forbid “carves a hole” out of whatever the permit allows.

The trace shows both outcomes:

• @0 — alice sells MSFT → allow (the permit matches; no forbid applies).
• @100 — alice sells AMZN → deny (the forbid matches and overrides the permit).
• @200 — bob calls GetStockInfo → deny (no permit matches, so the default-deny applies).

Referenced by guide/02-policy-language.md — The Policy Language.

Policy

// Deny-overrides semantics: permit selling shares generally, but a forbid
// carves out AMZN no matter the source order.
@id("permit-sell-shares")
permit ( principal, action == Drupe::Action::"SellShares", resource );

@id("forbid-sell-amzn")
forbid ( principal, action == Drupe::Action::"SellShares", resource )
when { context.input.stock == "AMZN" };

Schema

namespace Drupe {
  type ApproveSaleInput = {
    shares: Long,
    stock: String
  };

  type ApproveSaleOutput = {
    approved: Bool
  };

  type ContentFilterFinding = {
    severityScore: decimal
  };

  type GetStockInfoInput = {
    stock: String
  };

  type GetStockInfoOutput = {
    info: String
  };

  type PromptAttackFinding = {
    severityScore: decimal
  };

  type SellSharesInput = {
    shares: Long,
    stock: String
  };

  type SellSharesOutput = {
    proceeds: decimal
  };

  type SensitiveInfoFinding = {
    confidenceScore: decimal
  };

  type SystemContext = {
    now: datetime
  };

  entity Gateway;

  entity IamEntity = {
    id: String
  };

  entity OAuthUser = {
    id: String
  } tags String;

  entity UnauthenticatedUser;

  action "ApproveSale" in [Action::"CallTool"] appliesTo {
    principal: [IamEntity, OAuthUser, UnauthenticatedUser],
    resource: [Gateway],
    context: {
      input: ApproveSaleInput,
      output?: ApproveSaleOutput,
      system: SystemContext
    }
  };

  action "CallTool" in [Action::"Mcp"] appliesTo {
    principal: [OAuthUser, IamEntity, UnauthenticatedUser],
    resource: [Gateway],
    context: {
      system: SystemContext
    }
  };

  action "GetStockInfo" in [Action::"CallTool"] appliesTo {
    principal: [IamEntity, OAuthUser, UnauthenticatedUser],
    resource: [Gateway],
    context: {
      input: GetStockInfoInput,
      output?: GetStockInfoOutput,
      system: SystemContext
    }
  };

  action "Http" appliesTo {
    principal: [OAuthUser, IamEntity, UnauthenticatedUser],
    resource: [Gateway],
    context: {
      system: SystemContext
    }
  };

  action "InvokeAgent" in [Action::"Http"] appliesTo {
    principal: [OAuthUser, IamEntity, UnauthenticatedUser],
    resource: [Gateway],
    context: {
      input?: {      },
      system: SystemContext
    }
  };

  action "InvokeLLM" in [Action::"Http"] appliesTo {
    principal: [OAuthUser, IamEntity, UnauthenticatedUser],
    resource: [Gateway],
    context: {
      input?: {      },
      system: SystemContext
    }
  };

  action "Mcp" appliesTo {
    principal: [OAuthUser, IamEntity, UnauthenticatedUser],
    resource: [Gateway],
    context: {
      system: SystemContext
    }
  };

  action "SellShares" in [Action::"CallTool"] appliesTo {
    principal: [IamEntity, OAuthUser, UnauthenticatedUser],
    resource: [Gateway],
    context: {
      input: SellSharesInput,
      output?: SellSharesOutput,
      system: SystemContext
    }
  };

  action "UnknownTool" in [Action::"CallTool"] appliesTo {
    principal: [OAuthUser, IamEntity, UnauthenticatedUser],
    resource: [Gateway],
    context: {
      system: SystemContext
    }
  };
}

Trace

@0 scope(principal: Drupe::OAuthUser::"alice", resource: Drupe::Gateway::"gw1") request_context(input: { shares: 5, stock: "MSFT" }) Drupe::Action::"SellShares"::request(input: { shares: 5, stock: "MSFT" }, callerPrincipal: Drupe::OAuthUser::"alice", callerResource: Drupe::Gateway::"gw1", requestId: "u1")
@100 scope(principal: Drupe::OAuthUser::"alice", resource: Drupe::Gateway::"gw1") request_context(input: { shares: 5, stock: "AMZN" }) Drupe::Action::"SellShares"::request(input: { shares: 5, stock: "AMZN" }, callerPrincipal: Drupe::OAuthUser::"alice", callerResource: Drupe::Gateway::"gw1", requestId: "u2")
@200 scope(principal: Drupe::OAuthUser::"bob", resource: Drupe::Gateway::"gw1") request_context(input: { stock: "AMZN" }) Drupe::Action::"GetStockInfo"::request(input: { stock: "AMZN" }, callerPrincipal: Drupe::OAuthUser::"bob", callerResource: Drupe::Gateway::"gw1", requestId: "u3")

Expected Output

@0 (time point 0): ALLOW  [rules: 0]
@100 (time point 1): DENY  [rules: 1]
@200 (time point 2): DENY